Havertown vs. Drexel Hill: Where Should First-Time Buyers Look?
Nov 16, 2026 · @William Holder
Both are classic first-time-buyer towns in Delaware County, and the right pick usually comes down to two things: your budget and your priorities.
Drexel Hill is the more affordable way in — a median around $350,000 to $425,000 — with hard-to-beat access to Philadelphia. Havertown costs more — mid-to-high $500,000s — but you're buying into the highly regarded Haverford Township schools and a polished, walkable-suburb feel. If getting in affordably and commuting to the city matter most, lean Drexel Hill. If it's schools and more house, and your budget stretches, lean Havertown. Here's the full comparison.
Drexel Hill: the value and commute pick
If your first goal is getting into a home without overextending, Drexel Hill is one of the best values in Delaware County. The classic housing stock — sturdy stone twins, rowhomes, and colonials — means your money goes further, and the entry price is well below Havertown's.
The other big draw is location. Drexel Hill sits right next to the 69th Street transportation hub in Upper Darby, which plugs you into SEPTA's Market-Frankford Line, trolleys, and buses. For anyone commuting into Philadelphia, that's a serious everyday advantage — you can leave the car at home.
Two things to weigh honestly. First, Drexel Hill is part of the Upper Darby School District, a large district — if schools are a priority, look at the specific schools your home would feed into rather than relying on a label. Second, the effective tax rate is higher here (around 2.36%), though because home prices are lower, the actual dollar bill often isn't as far from Havertown's as the rate alone suggests. Run the real numbers on a specific house.
Best fit for: budget-conscious first-time buyers, city commuters, and anyone who wants the most home for their money close to Philadelphia.
Havertown: the schools and settled-suburb pick
Havertown (officially most of Haverford Township) is where a lot of buyers land when schools move to the top of the list. The Haverford Township School District is one of the most sought-after in the county, and that reputation is a big part of why homes here hold their value.
It also just has a certain feel — locals half-jokingly call it "Delco's Mayberry." Walkable commercial strips like Brookline Boulevard and the Oakmont section give it genuine town centers, with coffee shops, restaurants, and a strong community-events calendar. The housing leans more toward single-family homes and roomier colonials, though you'll still find classic twins.
The trade-off is price. The median runs in the mid-to-high $500,000s, meaningfully above Drexel Hill, so first-time buyers often need a bigger budget or have to compromise on size or condition to get in. The upside: the effective tax rate is lower here (around 1.58%), and the schools-plus-walkability combination tends to keep demand — and resale — strong.
Best fit for: buyers who prioritize schools and a polished, walkable suburb, and whose budget can stretch into the $500,000s.
So which should you pick?
There's no wrong answer here — both are proven first-time-buyer towns. It comes down to which of these sounds more like you:
Budget is the top constraint → Drexel Hill. You'll get in for less and usually get more square footage for the money.
Schools are the top priority → Havertown, for the Haverford Township district.
You commute to Philadelphia by transit → Drexel Hill, hands down, thanks to the 69th Street hub.
You want a walkable, settled-suburb feel and plan to stay a long time → Havertown.
You're optimizing resale and long-term value → both hold up well, but Havertown's schools give it a steady edge, while Drexel Hill's affordability keeps a deep buyer pool.
My honest take: don't choose the town in the abstract — choose it with real numbers in front of you. The right pick often becomes obvious once you see what your budget actually buys in each, side by side, including the tax difference.
Frequently asked questions
Is Drexel Hill a good place to live? For a lot of first-time buyers, yes — it offers affordable classic homes, an easy commute into Philadelphia, and a convenient, established community. It's part of the Upper Darby School District, so if schools are a priority, look closely at the specific schools your home would feed into.
Is Havertown expensive? It's one of the pricier first-time-buyer options in Delaware County — a median in the mid-to-high $500,000s — largely because of the strong Haverford Township schools and walkable-suburb appeal. You're paying more, but the tax rate is lower and demand stays steady.
Which has better schools, Havertown or Drexel Hill? Haverford Township (Havertown) is the more highly rated district overall. Upper Darby (Drexel Hill) is a large district with a range of schools — worth researching at the individual-school level rather than by reputation alone.
Which is better for commuting to Philadelphia? Drexel Hill, for transit commuters — it's right by the 69th Street hub with rail, trolley, and bus options. Havertown works too but leans more car-dependent.
Which is cheaper, Havertown or Drexel Hill? Drexel Hill, clearly, on home price — often $150,000 or more less at the median. Just remember its effective tax rate is higher, so compare the full monthly cost, not just the purchase price.
Not sure which fits you? Let's compare them side by side
The fastest way to settle the Havertown-vs-Drexel-Hill question is to see what your budget actually buys in each — real homes, real monthly costs, taxes included. If you're a first-time buyer trying to decide, I'm glad to pull current listings in both and walk through the trade-offs with you.
Call or text me directly at 484-744-4053 and we'll find the right fit for your budget and your priorities.